Skip to main content

Table 2 Individual study results, graft take rates and complication rates for cartilage palisade tympanoplasty compared to temporalis fascia

From: The palisade cartilage tympanoplasty technique: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Authors Palisade   Temporalis fascia
Number of Patients Overall take rate Complications Type of Complications Number of Patients Overall take rate Complications Types of Complications
Khan et al. [14] 223 97.8% 10.0% Persistent or recurrent perforation, otorrhea, infection 167 82.6% 17.3% Persistent or recurrent perforation
Kazikdas et al. [12] 23 95.7% 8.7% Perforation, otorrhea 28 75.0% 17.4% Persistent or recurrent perforation
Shishegar et al. [15] 27 100.0% 4.3% Infection, otorrhea 27 93.0% 25.0% Persistent or recurrent perforation
Vashishth et al. [17] 30 90.0% 0.0%   60 83.3% 18% Persistent or recurrent perforation, otorrhea, infection
Demirpehlivan et al.[16] 19 79.0% 10.0% Persistent or recurrent perforation, infection 67 80.6% 16.7% Persistent or recurrent perforation
Weighted average (SE) 96.0% (1.1%) 3.1% (1.0%) Weighted average (SE) 82.5% (2.0%) 17.9% (2.1%)  
  1. SE Standard Error