Skip to main content

Table 5 Review of inverted papilloma cohort studies per surgical approach with a minimal follow-up of 12 months (2005–2016)

From: Surgical management of inverted papilloma; a single-center analysis of 247 patients with long follow-up

Authors Year published Endoscopic
approach
Combined
approach
External
approach
Follow-up
(months)
   No. of recurrences / %) No. of recurrences /
total no. of patients (%)
No. of recurrences /
total no. of patients (%)
Mean Low High
Poetker et al. [12] 2005 0 / 8 (0.0) 1 / 4 (25.0)    29.8 12 80
Kamel et al. [13] 2005 3 / 52 (5.8)      65 24 160
Peng et al. [14] 2006      2 / 98 (2.0) 61 24 168
Minovi et al. [15] 2006 6 / 61 (9.8) 3 / 20 (15.0) 0 / 6 (0.0) 74 12 175
Mirza et al. [16] 2007 4 / 32 (12.5)    4 / 16 (25.0) 60 12 240
Harvinder et al. [17] 2008 0 / 5 (0.0)      23 12 36
Jurado-ramos et al. [18] 2008 4 / 34 (11.8)    8 / 18 (44.4) 54.3 12 60
Durucu et al. [19] 2009 2 / 23 (8.7) 1 / 14 (7.1) 3 / 19 (15.8) 35 16 42
Sham et al. [20] 2009 12 / 40 (30.0)    6 / 16 (37.5) 84 24 216
Rutherford et al. [21] 2010 0 / 2 (0.0)      19 15 24
Giotakis et al. [22] 2010 5 / 39 (12.8)    11 / 25 (44.0) 91 36 146
Gras-Cabrerizo et al. [23] 2010 10 / 57 (17.5)    7 / 22 (31.8)   12  
Pagella et al. [24] 2011 1 / 20 (5.0)      50 24 87
Dragonetti et al. [25] 2011 5 / 84 (6.0)      39 13 97
Lombardi et al. [26] 2011 12 / 198 (6.1) 0 / 14 (0.0)    53.8 24 192
Kim et al. [27] 2012 64 / 372 (17.2) 17 / 144 (11.8) 10 / 62 (16.1) 41 12  
Pagella et al. [28] 2014 1 / 73 (1.4)      58 18 138
Sciaretta et al. [29] 2014 7 / 103 (6.8)      57.7 24 167
Gu et al. [30] 2014 1 / 7 (14.3)    3 / 14 (21.4) 65 36 144
Erbek [31] 2015 0 / 8 (0.0)      30.8 12 60
Hong [32] 2015 0 / 6 (0.0) 3 / 25 (12.0)    55.6 36 93
Adriaensen [33] 2016 15 / 121 (12.4) 7 / 39 (17.9)     12 139
Healy [34] 2016 9 / 88 (10.2)      97.2 36  
Total   161 / 1433 (11.2) 32 / 260 (12.3) 54 / 296 (18.2) 54.5