Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of the eligible studies that were assessed for various outcomes (n = 17)

From: Comparison of the efficacy and safety of conventional curettage adenoidectomy with those of other adenoidectomy surgical techniques: a systematic review and network meta-analysis

Study name

Year

Country/Study location

Total sample size at baseline

Age in years (Range)

Gender

Characteristics of patients

Follow up time

Shorook Na'ara et al. [21]

2020

Haifa, Israel

58

1.2 to 15

M:58.6% F: 41.3%

Breating and sleeping problems

1 to 12 months

Secaattin Gu ̈ls et al. [3]

2019

Yozgat, Turkey

72

5 to 11

M: 50% F: 50%

Nasal airway obstruction with chronic postnasal discharge

1 to 7 days

Saroo Singh et al. [8]

2019

New Delhi, India

60

6 to 12

M: 78.3% F: 21.6%

Adenoid hypertrophy

3 months

Juneja et al. [10]

2018

New Delhi, India

50

5 to 12

M: 70% F: 30%

Nasal or aural symptoms due to adenoid hypertrophy

1 day to 3 months

Mularczyk et al. [23]

2018

Illinois,USA

101

 < 18 years

NR

Adenoid hypertrophy

3 days

Hussein and Al-Juboori [36]

2012

Hilla, Iraq

40

4 to 20

M: 40% F: 60%

Nasal airway obstruction with sleep disordered breathing, epistaxis, discharge, and otological symptoms

Post-operative period (short follow-up): Exact duration NR

Baker et al. [28]

2012

Virginia, USA

61

1 to 12

M: 60.6% F: 39.3%

Adenoid hypertrophy

Post-operative period (short follow-up): Exact duration NR

Öztürket al [29]

2012

Istanbul, Turkey

56

1.8 to 15.6

M:54.7% F: 45.3%

Nasal airway obstruction with sleep disordered breathing and otitis media and chronic rhinosuinitis

6 months

Bradoo et al. [37]

2011

Mumbai, India

32

5 ot 13

M:54.8% F: 45.2%

Mouth breathing, adenooid facies, ear problems, and saliva drooling

3 months

Songu et al. [30]

2010

Izmir, Turkey

38

8 to 12

M:52.6% F: 47.3%

Adenoid hypertrophy

3 months

Datta et al. [24]

2009

Mumbai, India

60

6 to 12

NR

Adenoid hypertrophy

1 to 7 days

Al-Mazrou et al. [27]

2009

Riyadh, Saudi Arabia

40

3 to 17

M: 50% F: 50

Snoring, obstructive sleep apnea and enlarged adenoids

3 to 24 months

Jonas et al. [3]

2007

Cape Town, South Africa

100

1.2 months to 13 years

M: 49% F: 51%

Snoring, obstructive sleep apnea, nasal airway obstruction, chronic otitis media, and enlarged adenoids

6 months

Shapiro et al. [25]

2007

California, USA

47

2 to 16

M: 59.5% F: 38.3%

Adenoid hypertrophy

14 days

Tarantino et al. [26]

2004

Genova, Italy

600

2 to 10

NR

nasal airway obstruction, nasal dyspnea, noisy breathing, otitis media, and hearing loss

Post-operative period (short follow-up): Exact duration NR

Stanislaw et al. [31]

2000

New York, USA

177

1 to 13

M: 57.6% F: 42.3%

Adenoid hypertrophy

1 to 7 days

Clemens et al. [32]

1997

USA

34

4.9 ± 2.8 and 6.9 ± 4.1

NR

Adenoid hypertrophy

1 month